The wild banana, the predecessor of the cultivated fruit favourite, does reproduce sexually, pollinating their flowers in the usual way and having the botanical equivalent of sex. Warning courtesy of that great creationist guru Ray Comfort. "Ignorant" means you do not know. With a sleepy, groggy voice, he made the following observation: “You know, I understand that Intelligent Design and Creationism are both valid theories, but listening to the sounds coming from that room is the best proof of Evolution we have. Fossils provide solid evidence that organisms from the past are not the same as those found today, and fossils show a progression of evolution. For those of you who aren't familiar, this is what a word they like to call Asians who "act white". It went up against Satoshi's Charmeleon in PZ08 and lost. Designs in DNA; Epic Failures of Evolution Series. If evolution weren't true, there would be no reason to expect these signs of common descent. Ray suggests the debate between him and Dawkins be called "Banana man vs. Alien man" and let the audience decide who is the ignorant fool. The evolution of the banana, star of the Western fruit bowl Sequencing the banana genome reveals that domestication of the fruit was a complicated process. Stupid video about atheist rebuttal points. Most atheists do not choose to disbelieve that a god exists because that is what they want. The theory of evolution gives us a unifying theory to explain the similarities and differences within life’s organisms and processes. Professor Dawkins actually does have degrees and participates in scientific academia, the process of peer reviewing, and performs actual scientific studies. Ray is so taken aback by people laughing at this video that he now claims that it was a hoax,[12] perpetrated by atheists:[13]. It encompasses a wide variety of topics, from astronomy to chemistry to biology. Modern bananas are sterile, containing only tiny residual seeds, so new banana plants are propagated from cuttings. Before you start the first level in this mission, “Eating dinosaurs for dinner,” watch the introductory video and answer questions 1–2 below. While the design aspects of the banana are pretty clear, Ray never mentions that bananas only grow between 30 degrees north latitude and 30 degrees south latitude. [3] A hobbit-like species of human lived about 18,000 years ago. Moving on, so according to Ray, God gave tribes of men the knowledge some 10,000 or more years ago (much further back than he believes humans existed) to breed wolves into dogs which could fit in a man-made moving car in the 20th century. ... (BSV) have been recorded worldwide where Musa spp. There are also very few ergonomic properties associated with these fruits, either with them being large and bulky or covered in spines—again, demonstrating the opposite of the simple "pull tab" Comfort is so proud of. Ray Comfort assumes that proof of the existence of a benevolent powerful being would be a nightmare to atheists. In this video, evangelist Ray Comfort introduces what he calls "The Atheist's Nightmare," the banana that we all know and love. A lot of… Absence of evidence does not prove anything; a lack of information is not a valid argument against the principles of evolution or for any other theory. cultivation on Mabuyag Island, Torres Strait. ©2020 Verizon Media. A lack of information is merely a signal that more research needs to be done. "Tracking the banana: its significance in early agriculture". The sterile domesticated banana is the result of ancient crossbreeding between wild species. Because, supposedly, the banana was proof of God's design. Scientists determine the age of fossils and categorize them from all over the world to determine when the organisms lived relative to each other. Wrong, Ray presented the complex design elements of the Coke can with the complex designs of the god fruit, and was thus criticized for it. By the way, this sort of misreading is itself evidence of being a banana republic. What is the most puzzling though is their actual relationship to other types of birds. Was Ray calling the Coke can the "Atheist Nightmare"? In contrast, the larynx in a chimp, for example, sits higher in the throat than in a human. declares Comfort, before detailing the many user-friendly features of bananas, which include its "non-slip surface," "tab at the top" for easy opening, and convenient shape which is "even curved toward the face to make the whole process so much easier.". Either way looks rather bad for him. This is incredibly common for most, if not all, fruits, vegetables, and even animals that we use for food or to improve their utility to us in terms of ease of cultivation or taste. [15]. The universal genetic code. In fact, some of us have probably been hearing it for the majority of our lives. Now if you go to the top of the banana, you'll find, as with the soda can makers have placed a tab at the top, so God has placed a tab at the top. If Dawkins accepts the offer, it gives the false impression that Ray is on an equal intellectual level with Dawkins. Iskra-Caruana ML(1), Chabannes M(2), Duroy PO(2), Muller E(2). The point is that coke can was designed with these features in mind; therefore, so was the banana. And they'd keep indefinitely without going bad or losing their vitamin content. But as it turns out, it was not God's design, Next, the video tries to boost Ray's book, First of all, Comfort getting his book to #38 on its opening day—is this supposed to be impressive? Evolutionism is a world-view, which seeks to explain every aspect of this world in which we live. Because islands provide isolated habitats where there is little chance of interbreeding with mainland species, evolutionary theory … The durian fruit also possesses an incredibly pungent aroma that has seen the transport and storage of the fruit banned in some public places. The evolution process for the Flamingo is full of theories, questions, wholes, and pieces of evidence. The argument for the banana being designed is based on the following characteristics: Ironically, these features do point to an intelligent designer, but it certainly isn't God, as we shall see later. Someday, perhaps? What about a God who is sometimes benevolent during this life but treats most of us malevolently after death? Most of them -- humans included -- at least get to find a fairly comfortable position to push a living being out of their birth canal. In the Pokémon Zensho manga. Scientists are unsure how to deal with the crisis which potentially could destroy the livelihoods of rich and poor farmers worldwide. Additionally, Dawkins would not be the "alien man"; he would more likely be the "Aliens are a much better possible explanation than your god, provided intelligent design is true" man. But the type of logic used when looking at specific design aspects of natural products can be used to prove the non-existence of a designer god too. References. Evolution - Evolution - The science of evolution: The central argument of Darwin’s theory of evolution starts with the existence of hereditary variation. 38 (6): 12-13. [9] Another example is that until a few decades ago, the banana best known in the developed world was the Gros Michel variety (said to have been a bit tastier than the Cavendish we eat today). The full version opens with an appraisal of the design aspects of a soda can; these include pointing out the outer casing to contain the liquid, the size which is designed to fit the hand, and the ring-pull that gives you easy access. It has a simple "colour code" to show ripeness: Green, too early. Also, there are people who just don't like eating bananas, and some who have potentially fatal allergic reactions to them. [13] A descended larynx, which allows humans to speak, evolved roughly 350,000 year ago. Evolution - Evolution - Adaptive radiation: The geographic separation of populations derived from common ancestors may continue long enough so that the populations become completely differentiated species before ever regaining sympatry and the opportunity to interbreed. Both the durian fruit and the pineapple have hard outer surfaces that require a sharp knife or hand axe to cut through, which is the exact opposite of the cases of the banana that is easy to get into. Notice it has a point at the top for ease of entry. This is a small subtlety, and not essential to und… See. I doubt whether when some Swiss guy complains about some problem in Switzerland that the listener automatically assumes it’s a direct attack on the Prime Minister. You feel insulted and "dehumanized" when scientists say that people evolved from other life forms, but you have no problem with the Biblical claim that we were created from dirt. analyzing the chromosome complements of some banana cultivars. The overemphasis of GMO banana and papaya over the corn, soybeans, cotton, and canola that make up more than 99 percent of GMO acres turns the real-world situation on its head. WHAT DO YOU THINK? According to Ray Comfort and other like-minded Christian fundamentalists the overwhelming majority of people end up in Hell. Ray Comfort's 2006 Hysterical Banana Argument Demonstrates What Creationists Mean By 'Proof', Thou Shalt Not Kill. What comfort didn't realize is that the banana has in fact been designed, by us. Is it proof of evolution when monkeys spit out banana seeds? Karen, Yes this is possible. Or have vaccines in them for easier application and distribution or countless other attributes that have been pipe dreams of genetic engineers around the world for years. It's just the right shape for the human mouth. All of our food, whether they are crops of domesticated animals, have been bred for thousands of years in order to preserve traits that we like and find useful. The differences between species on islands compared to mainlands provide a compelling example of evolution. Failures of Evolution: Speciation of Goatsbeard; Failures of Evolution: Ontogeny Recapitulates Phylogeny 1. It would be restored by the development of antibiotics to which bacteria cannot evolve resistance. There is a "pull tab" at the "top" for easy access. For those who are not aware of the significance of that date, February 12 is. Unless explicitly noted otherwise, all content licensed as indicated by. This "apology" video was posted by Ray in 2009. To people who argue Banana's as proof, would it not also prove evolution, as monkeys have the very same hands? In fact, the banana as we know it is the result of careful artificial selection by humans over the course of many years. The soft, yellow flesh of the edible varieties is the result of collective mutations cultivated thousands of years ago. So either he lied in this video back in 2009, or after all these years of criticism and mockery he's lying in 2017 in his new book (or has deluded himself into thinking he knew it all along). Multidisciplinary evidence for early banana (Musa cvs.) From his side of the bed, Ken stirred. Five Proofs of Evolution. There are also failures to respect decent health and safety standards, and the evidence of the devastation caused to human health and the natural environment by toxic chemicals and intensive monoculture plantation production is increasingly evident. Dawkins is not afraid of anything (. 101 evidences for a young age of the Earth and the universe. Now if you study a well-made banana, you'll find, on the far side, there are 3 ridges. On the close side, two ridges. 1 CHAPTER 1 1.0 INTRODUCTION 1.1 Banana Banana is a monocotyledonous, perennial herb within the order Zingiberales, and the family Musaceae.

banana proof of evolution

Rhyme Of Night, The Blue Elephant Netflix, List Of Characters In Bfdi, Ben And Jerry's Ice Cream, Honda Civic Vs Toyota Corolla Nairaland,